Photo

Robin Harwood Free

Recent Comments

  1. about 3 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    Do not confuse him with philosopher John McTaggart Ellis McTaggart. He was an idealist metaphysician, and is particularly famous for his argument to demonstrate the unreality of time. You will assuredly be surprised to learn that, despite his name, he was not a Scotsman.

  2. about 3 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    I approve of her punctilious adherence to the scientifically established specifications for snow crystals. Santa has a whole division of elves who work on the designs, and they scrupulously stick to six points.

  3. about 4 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    Today’s question is one that has plagued me since childhood.

    Is fairy bread pre-planned, or is it a desperate, last minute, resort of mothers who realise they haven’t got enough cakes for the party?

  4. about 4 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    And since the more cerebral of us refuse to even contemplate the question of whether Brad’s quiff could exist in any possible world, we will continue to ignore the TV and discuss one of The Great Questions Of The Ages.

  5. about 13 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    I think both of those are cheesy, second-rate, sentimental slop, Oscars notwithstanding.

  6. about 13 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    That’s 2021/11/15 in real time.

  7. about 13 hours ago on Breaking Cat News

    It really annoys me. But most things do.

  8. 1 day ago on Breaking Cat News

    It is most irritating. We are trying to sort out exactly what position David Lewis takes on the metaphysical implications of counterfactual conditionals (see example below) and we keep hearing bits of dialogue we have absolutely no interest in. We forget them instantly, but they keep coming.

    (Consider the statement “If Kit had smuggled the catnip, Father O’Kittery would have given Kit a second chance.” If this statement is true, Lewis contends that there exists a possible world in which Kit’s counterpart smuggled the catnip. But in what way does that world exist? And who is this Kit, anyway? )

    And don’t get me started on people who put “would have” in the “if” clause.

  9. 1 day ago on Breaking Cat News

    Look up the Child Migration Scheme. The film “Oranges and Sunshine” was based on the Australian part.

  10. 1 day ago on Breaking Cat News

    That seems a reasonable line of inquiry to pursue.